Talk:Redwall OC- Rolt Irontail./@comment-2246928-20150211162106/@comment-3135907-20150314181150

They're Salia's intellectual property, and she still has the ability to access this site. She may not have the characters saved anywhere else. And as a rule, pages aren't deleted unless

1) the page is obscene, vulgar or spam,

2) that they are not related to the site's topic (pages for tanks, spaceships, and non-redwall characters, etc.) and

3) that a user is offended on moral, racial, or religious grounds.

Reason 3 does not, however, extend to people saying, "Delete this page because I'm religiously offended!" unless the page actually attacks someone's religious convictions or the lack thereof personally (e.g., "Everyone should hate John Doe because he is a Buddhist"). A person can't suggest, for example, that a page be deleted because it contains religious or secular content- unless it is obscene, vulgar or a personal attack on another person's religion. Also, pages that are intended to put other beliefs or convictions down are for obvious reasons a speedy deletion issue. A userpage saying "I'm a Confucian." is not an attack on other beliefs or convictions and as such won't be removed.

But the reason I removed the Category:Speedydelete from it was because there was no Speedy Deletion Notice outlining the reason why the article should be deleted. The Speedy Deletion Notice can be easily accessed here.

Also, these characters belong to Salia. She paid for her offense via a block. Nowhere in the rules is it outlined that a user who breaks the rules must be further punished by having their personal character records destroyed. That's a personal attack on Salia herself instead of a simple ban, because it is possbile that such action would hurt Salia if this character page is the only existing record of this character. Deleting the page would be an act of spite.

I'm not protecting Salia; this extends to everyone's character records. Don't you think that's better for everyone? What if you were in a banned user's situation? Would you want your character records deleted forever?